Flight Simulator vs Real Aircraft Training: Which Should You Start With?
Comprehensive comparison of simulator and aircraft training for student pilots. Learn why the sim-first approach can save time and money while building better skills.
The best approach: Start with simulators, then transition to aircraft. This isn't about replacing real flight—it's about arriving at the aircraft prepared. Students who complete thorough simulator training first typically need fewer expensive aircraft hours and feel more confident from their first real flight.
Below we break down exactly what each training method offers, their limitations, and how to combine them effectively.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Aspect | Simulator | Real Aircraft |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per hour | $50-150 | $170-350 |
| Weather dependency | None | High |
| Scheduling flexibility | Very high | Limited |
| Emergency practice | Unlimited, safe | Limited, risky |
| Physical sensations | Approximated | Real G-forces |
| FAA loggable hours | Limited (ATD/BATD) | All hours count |
| Location | City-based | Airport required |
| Mistake consequences | None - restart | Real risk |
Why Start with Simulator Training?
1. Master Procedures Without Time Pressure
In a real aircraft, every minute costs money and you're managing actual risk. In a simulator, you can pause, repeat, and perfect each procedure until it becomes automatic. This builds the "muscle memory" that frees your brain for higher-level decision-making in real flight.
2. Practice Emergencies Safely
Engine failures, electrical fires, instrument malfunctions—these are critical to practice but dangerous to simulate in real aircraft. In a simulator, you can experience every emergency scenario repeatedly until your response is instinctive.
3. No Weather Cancellations
In the NYC area, weather cancels 30-50% of scheduled flight lessons. This disrupts learning momentum and extends training timelines. Simulators let you maintain consistent progress regardless of weather.
4. City-Based Convenience
Our Jersey City facility is accessible via PATH, bus, or car—no 1-2 hour drive to an airport. This makes it easier to train frequently, which accelerates learning.
What Simulators Can't Replace
Simulators are preparation, not replacement. You absolutely need real aircraft time for:
- Physical sensations: Real G-forces, vibrations, and motion cues
- Depth perception: Judging height during landing takes real practice
- Wind effects: Actual crosswinds and turbulence handling
- Real-world decision making: Actual consequences sharpen judgment
- Checkride preparation: You'll take your test in a real aircraft
The Optimal Training Path
- 1Ground School + Simulator (8-12 weeks)
Learn theory and master procedures in our Jersey City facility
- 2Transition to Aircraft (2-3 sessions)
Familiarization flights to experience real sensations
- 3Flight Training (40-60 hours)
Focus on skills that require real aircraft: landings, cross-country, maneuvers
- 4Checkride Prep
Final preparation and practical test
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources & References
- FAA Advisory Circular 61-136B - FAA Approval of Aviation Training Devices
- AOPA - Simulation in Pilot Training
- Journal of Aviation/Aerospace Education & Research - Simulator Training Effectiveness
Ready to Start Your Aviation Journey?
Adults and student pilots: book a free 15-minute simulator visit. Kids ages 6–17: start with our $25 trial class.